The paper by Luzzati et al. (2027), "Material use and its relationship with per capita income: A panel data analysis at the global level", examines whether economic growth eventually leads to a reduction in material consumption, as proposed by the Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) hypothesis.
Using data for up to 147 countries over the period 1970–2019, the authors analyse two indicators: Domestic Material Consumption (DMC), which measures materials directly used within an economy, and Material Footprint (MF), which accounts for the materials required to satisfy domestic consumption, including those embodied in imports. They employ semiparametric and parametric panel-data methods to investigate the relationship between income per capita and absolute material use, without imposing a predetermined functional form.
The findings provide no evidence of an Environmental Kuznets Curve for either indicator: material use generally increases with income, with no systematic turning point at higher income levels.
Moreover, the relationship has become stronger over time. Estimated income elasticities increased from approximately 0.40 in 1970–1989 to 0.58 in 1993–2019, indicating that economic growth has become more material-intensive.
Although some high-income countries show stabilisation or declining values for DMC, this often reflects the outsourcing of material-intensive production rather than a reduction in their material footprint. Indeed, 87.6% of countries experiencing income growth also experienced increases in both DMC and MF.
The authors conclude that economic growth alone does not generate absolute decoupling from material use. Achieving meaningful reductions in global resource consumption will therefore require deliberate policy interventions addressing both production and consumption, alongside development pathways that avoid replicating the resource-intensive trajectories of wealthy economies.
Read the full paper here.